Michael Holland - Updated on August 23rd, 2024
Using our innovative SENTY75 system, we analyzed 75 recent customer reviews and laid all the cards on the table in this article.
So, keep reading to discover the surprises we found.
What is Sicilian Oven?
Sicilian Oven is an Italian-American restaurant that serves a range of Italian dishes, but specializes in wood-fired pizzas.
The restaurant, which offers a sports bar vibe, complete with flickering big screen tv’s all around, opened in Coral Springs more than a decade ago.
As you see from the ratings below, this place has been a model of consistency.
The restaurant has piled up more than 1,500+ lifetime Google reviews with a 4.5 overall rating.
And the SENTY75 current sentiment score of 4.5 confirms their attention to delivering consistent quality.
For this reason, the restaurant made it onto our 2024 top restaurants list and was named Best Pizza Restaurant for Watching Sports.
But, let’s go further into the details.
Top Current Customer Sentiments
First, here are the overall top positive and negative sentiments that recent diners shared:
Positive Sentiments Explained
The Positive Sentiments table captures the essence of what makes Sicilian Oven a local favorite – an outstanding dining experience that keeps customers coming back for more:
– Great food (42 mentions): You’ll be treated to a culinary delight with every visit. Customers rave about the authentic flavors and high-quality ingredients.
– Excellent service (25 mentions): Expect attentive and professional staff who go above and beyond to ensure your satisfaction.
– Friendly staff (12 mentions): You’ll feel right at home with the warm and welcoming team at Sicilian Oven.
– Authentic Italian (7 mentions): The pizzas other dishes were frequently praised for their exceptional taste, quality, and authenticity.
– Welcoming atmosphere (15 mentions): The restaurant’s ambiance adds to the overall positive experience, creating a comfortable and inviting space for your meal.
"Sicilian Oven impresses with its authentic flavors and a cozy ambiance, serving up delectable pizzas that showcase the rich culinary heritage of Sicily."
Negative Sentiments Explained
While overwhelmingly positive, a few customers noted areas for improvement:
– Cold food (4 mentions): A small number of customers reported receiving cold food with delivery orders.
– Loud music (1 mentions): Some diners found the music volume to be disruptive to their dining experience.
– Slow service (1 mentions): A couple of reviews mentioned slower-than-expected service during busy times.
– Rude staff (4 mentions): While rare, there were isolated incidents of less-than-friendly service reported.
It’s important to note that these negative sentiments were far outweighed by positive experiences. Most issues appear to be isolated incidents rather than systemic problems.
Top Foods & Dishes
Next, these tables reveal the top positive and negative foods mentioned in the reviews:
Positively Mentioned Foods/Dishes Explained
Sicilian Oven’s menu is a hit parade of Italian favorites, with pizza taking center stage. Let’s dive into the dishes that have customers raving:
– Pizza (25 mentions): Sicilian Oven’s pizza is consistently praised for its authentic taste and quality. Whether you’re a traditionalist or adventurous eater, you’ll find a pie to satisfy your cravings.
– Sicilian salad (12 mentions): A refreshing favorite that’s more than just a side dish. Packed with flavor and fresh ingredients, it’s a must-try for any visit.
– Eggplant dishes (8 mentions): From eggplant parmigiana to the “Stack of Sicily,” these dishes are a hit with vegetarians and meat-eaters alike.
– Chicken dishes (7 mentions): Whether it’s the Pollo Gabriella or chicken parm, the poultry options are crowd-pleasers.
– Garlic bread (5 mentions): A simple classic done right, perfect for starting your meal or accompanying your main course.
But don’t stop there! Customers also rave about the meatballs, pasta dishes, and appetizers like calamari. Sicilian Oven has something to satisfy every palate.
Negatively Mentioned Foods/Dishes Explained
While the positive reviews far outweigh the negative, a few dishes received isolated critiques:
– Broccoli rabe (1 mention): One customer felt they received mostly stalks instead of the more desirable leafy parts.
– Caponata (1 mention): A traditionalist found the preparation not authentic to Sicilian cuisine.
– Wings (1 mention): There was a single instance of burnt wings, which seems to be an isolated incident.
Again, these negative mentions are few and far between, often countered by numerous positive reviews of the same dishes.
Further Breakdown of Pizza Mentions
The Positive Foods table above mentioned pizza generically 25 times. So we dug deeper to see if diners shouted out any specific pie names from the menu. Here’s what we found:
1. Wood-fired pizza: 5 mentions
2. The Joey D pizza: 3 mentions
3. The Corleone pizza: 3 mentions
As you can see, reviewers primarly mentioned “wood-fired”, and how they love the authentic taste and crispy crust.
But there were positive mentions of the Joey D and the Corleone as favorites.
Perceived Quality/Value Ratings for Key Foods/Dishes
Next, this table summarizes the perceived quality and value ratings for key items on Sicilian Oven’s menu:
Let’s dive into what these ratings mean for your potential dining experience:
• Pizza reigns supreme: With a near-perfect rating of 4.8 and the highest frequency of mentions, pizza is Sicilian Oven’s standout offering.
• Salad sensation: The Sicilian salad boasts a perfect 5.0 rating, making it a must-try item. It’s not just a side dish – customers rave about its freshness and flavor, suggesting it could be a meal in itself.
• Eggplant excellence: With a 4.9 rating, eggplant dishes are another highlight of the menu. Whether you’re trying the eggplant parmigiana or the “Stack of Sicily,” you’re in for a treat.
• Consistent quality across the board: Most items on the menu score above 4.5, indicating high overall satisfaction with the food quality. From chicken dishes to pasta and appetizers like garlic bread and meatballs, you can expect a consistently enjoyable meal.
The only item with a rating below 4.0 is the broccoli rabe, which received mixed reviews due to one instance where mostly stalks were served.
Important Note: Usually, the most passionate clients leave positive and negative reviews. So when you see a rating based on 2 or 3 mentions, don’t take that as the gospel since the sample size is so tiny. Other diners likely left great reviews but didn’t mention any particular food/dish.
Additional Bites
Here are some additional key insights uncovered in the reviews that you might find valuable:
• Many reviewers mentioned the restaurant’s lively and family-friendly atmosphere, so it can get noisy during peak hours.
• Several reviewers noted that the restaurant offers outdoor seating.
• There is a bar area where you can eat and drink for a more casual dining option.
• Multiple reviews mentioned that the restaurant is often busy, especially during peak hours.
• Some reviewers mentioned daily drink specials.
• The restaurant offers gluten-free pizza options.
• A few reviews mentioned using Sicilian Oven for catering events.
• Many customers commented on the generous portion sizes, suggesting good value for money.
• A couple of reviews mentioned having to park a little further away during busy times.
"Can’t miss. This place is awesome. Wings are amazing and the pizza is on point."
Restaurant Cleanliness
Sicilian Oven has several South Florida locations. At the time of this review, the Coral Springs restaurant was last inspected by the Florida Health Department in February 2024.
The inspector found 4 violations and assigned a status of “Follow-up Inspection Required”.
It was not shut down due to something egregious like for roaches or rodents. Instead, the unresolved matters appear to be related to repeated administrative compliance failures.
Here is a summary of the findings:
• No certified restaurant food manager on-site during inspection.
• Food stored improperly. (Corrected during inspection.)
• Temperature Control (All Corrected During Inspection):
– Cold pasta temperature too high. Corrected, but resulted in a $400 fine due to repeat violation.
– Meatballs not hot enough.
– Gorgonzola cheese not cooling quickly enough.
• Missing vacuum breaker at the outside mop sink.
(Corrected during inspection.)
You can view the latest inspection report by visiting this link.
Restaurant Profile:
–Type of Cuisine: Pizza & Italian Dishes
–Menu Options: Full Dinner, Lunch, Full Bar, Delivery, Pickup
–Ambiance: Comfortable, Family-friendly
–Average Prices: Pizzas ($21), Entrees ($17)
Location & Hours:
- Address: 10140 W Sample Rd, Coral Springs, FL 33065 (see map below)
- Phone: (954) -340-3001
- Hours of operation: Monday-Saturday from 11:30 a.m.-10 p.m. and Sundays from noon-10 p.m.
- Website: sicilianoven.com
Sicilian Oven Review - FAQ
What is SENTY75?
SENTY™ is a cutting-edge system that cuts through stale data to capture the current sentiment toward businesses. In contrast to Google, which blindly combines all feedback, SENTY75 laser-focuses on the freshest detailed reviews across platforms like Google, Yelp, and Facebook, filtering out any without substantive comments.
This approach provides an authentic read on how the public feels about a business. The “75” in SENTY75 represents the ideal number of recent reviews analyzed to accurately gauge the sentiments surrounding Coral Springs restaurants.
Is Sicilian Oven worth visiting despite the recent health inspection concerns?
Yes, Sicilian Oven is still worth visiting. The restaurant’s exceptional pizza, Sicilian salad, and other Italian dishes consistently receive high praise from customers. While the recent health inspection revealed some administrative compliance issues, most were immediately corrected on-site.
The restaurant’s popularity, friendly atmosphere, and attentive staff contribute to a positive dining experience.
Conclusion
Sicilian Oven offers a delightful dining experience with exceptional pizza, salads, and Italian favorites.
With stellar Google and SENTY75 current sentiment ratings, you’ll be in good hands. So, take your crew for a wood-fired pie and enjoy the game.
Share this article