Michael Holland - Updated on August 1st, 2024
In this review of Annie’s Pizza, you’ll get the scoop on what recent customers said about the restaurant and how they feel overall.
To uunlock the secrets, we used our innovative SENTY75 system to analyze recent reviews and spill the tea without fear or favor.
So, if you want an honest assessment of this pizza (and more) joint, let’s go.
What is Annie's Pizza?
Annie’s is a pizzeria in Coral Springs that serves a variety of Italian-American dishes, with a specialty in New York style pies. The restaurant was established in 2000 and has a loyal following.
Just look at their Google and SENTY75 ratings.
With a Google rating of 4.6 based on nearly 700 reviews, it has displayed outstanding consistency over time.
Their SENTY75 rating of 4.8 reflects an even higher current bump in delivering high-quality experiences to its customers.
Annie’s further distinguished itself in our 2024 restaurant survey as the people’s choice, the Best Pizzeria for Takeout and Delivery, and the highest-rated eatery in town.
Now, let’s see what makes this place a local favorite.
Top Overall Customer Sentiments
First, the following tables address the top 5 overall positive and negative vibes that customers expressed about the restaurant:
Positive Sentiments Explained:
The Positive Sentiments table captures the essence of what makes Annie’s Pizza a local favorite:
– Delicious food (36 mentions): You’ll be treated to mouth-watering dishes that keep customers returning for more.
– Friendly staff (22 mentions): Expect a warm welcome from the team who’ll make your visit enjoyable.
– Large portions (8 mentions): Prepare for generous servings that’ll satisfy your hunger and provide great value.
"Best Pizza in town. Friendly people. Consistent. Eat at the counter or take out."
Negative Sentiments Explained:
While the negative sentiments are far few, they provide insights into areas where some customers feel Annie’s could improve:
– Limited Seating (2 mentions): Annie’s has counter and outdoor seating dining. Some customers expressed disappointment about the lack of sit-down.
– There were a couple of mentions about flavorless food and an incorrect order.
Overall, these few negative sentiments highlight just how exceptional the restaurant is compared to its peers.
Top Foods & Dishes
Next, let’s examine the top 5 specific foods/dishes customers felt most passionate about from their reviews – positively and negatively:
Positively Mentioned Foods/Dishes Explained:
Just look at these superb dishes dominating the positives:
– Pizza that earns raves (23 mentions): You’ll find slices and pies that rival New York-style pizzerias.
– Subs that satisfy (11 mentions): These sandwiches are a hit from classic Italian to Philly cheesesteaks.
– Addictive garlic rolls (5 mentions): A perfect side or starter to complement your meal.
– Chicken Parm that impresses (4 mentions): This Italian-American staple is done right at Annie’s.
– Cheesesteaks that win hearts (4 mentions): A taste of Philly right in your neighborhood.
Negatively Mentioned Foods/Dishes Explained:
While the positive reviews far outweigh the negative, it’s worth noting the few criticisms to give a balanced view:
– Gluten-free pizza (1 mention): One customer found it disappointing, describing it as “awful.”
– Cheesesteak (1 mention): Despite being popular, one review mentioned a lack of flavor.
– Calzone (1 mention): One customer was surprised to see ricotta cheese, which they didn’t expect.
Again, these negatives are isolated incidents among many positive reviews.
Perceived Quality/Value Ratings for Key Foods/Dishes
Next, the following table summarizes the perceived quality/value ratings for key foods and dishes mentioned in the reviews:
Highlights:
• Pizza reigns supreme: With a near-perfect rating of 4.9 and the highest frequency of mentions (23), Annie’s Pizza lives up to its reputation. Customers consistently praise the pizza’s taste, quality, and authentic New York style.
• Subs and sides are crowd-pleasers: Subs, garlic rolls, and chicken parmesan all received perfect 5.0 ratings, indicating high customer satisfaction. The subs, in particular, are frequently mentioned (11 times), suggesting they’re a popular choice among patrons.
• Cheesesteaks are a hit: With a solid 4.5 rating, cheesesteaks are well-liked by most customers. The slightly lower rating compared to other top items might be due to one mention of lack of flavor, but overall, they’re still highly regarded.
Overall, Annie’s Pizza demonstrates consistently high quality across its menu, with most items receiving excellent ratings.
Additional Bites
Here are some additional insights that customers shared in reviews that you might find helpful:
• Catering services: Several reviews mentioned Annie’s Pizza’s excellent catering services for events like teacher appreciation luncheons and family gatherings.
• Delivery option: Customers appreciated the reliability and timeliness.
• Lunch specials: There were mentions of attractive lunch specials, including a popular two-slice and drink deal.
• Consistency: Many long-time customers (some mentioning 9-20 years of patronage) noted the consistent quality.
• House-made items: Some reviews mentioned that certain sauces and dressings are made in-house.
"A small fav pizza place that never disappoints! Huge slices, and varied menu of Italian dishes and deli sandwiches with a few stools to eat in and outside, fast, friendly and accommodating staff."
Restaurant Cleanliness
Here is the result of Annie’s November 2023 restaurant inspection by the Florida Health Department.
Restaurant Profile:
- Type of Cuisine: Pizzas, Pasta Dinners, Subs, & Wings
- Menu Options: Lunch & Dinner, Takeout & Delivery
- Ambiance: Small location with counter dining, outdoor seating
- Average Prices: Medium Pizza ($20), Pasta Dinner ($16)
Location & Hours:
- Address: 11348 Wiles Rd, Coral Springs, FL 33076
- Phone: (954) 575-1132
- Hours of operation: Monday-Saturday from 11 a.m.-10 p.m., Sunday (Closed)
- Website: annies-pizza.com/
Annie's Pizza Review - FAQ
What is SENTY75?
Offering a refreshingly current perspective, SENTY™ analyzes only the latest detailed reviews with comments from Google, Yelp, and Facebook.
In stark contrast to Google’s approach of combining all feedback over the business’s life, SENTY75 surfaces an authentic understanding of how people genuinely feel about a company right now by ignoring old reviews and those with no comments.
The “75” represents the ideal number of fresh reviews examined to gauge sentiment for Coral Springs restaurants accurately.
What makes Annie's Pizza stand out from other pizzerias in the area?
Annie’s Pizza stands out with its authentic New York-style pizza, diverse menu, and exceptional customer service.
Their consistently high-quality food, generous portions, and efficient service have created a loyal customer base.
Whether dining in, taking out, or ordering delivery, patrons enjoy affordable prices and a range of options from pizza to pasta. Annie’s commitment to quality and customer satisfaction makes it a local favorite.
Wrap Up.
Annie’s Pizza is a local gem that offers exceptional pizzas, diverse menu options, and outstanding service.
With consistently high ratings, generous portions, and affordable prices, it’s a go-to spot for quality Italian-American cuisine. Check it out.
Share this article